The Impact of the Sahara Desert on Nomadic Migration in North Africa

Table of Contents

The Sahara Desert stands as one of the most formidable geographical features on Earth, spanning approximately 9 million square kilometers across the African continent. For millennia, this vast expanse of sand, rock, and extreme climate has profoundly shaped the migration patterns, cultural development, and survival strategies of nomadic communities throughout North Africa. Far from being merely an obstacle, the Sahara has served as both a barrier and a bridge, influencing the movement of peoples, the exchange of goods and ideas, and the evolution of unique adaptive strategies that continue to fascinate researchers and travelers alike.

The Sahara as a Dynamic Geographical Force

The Sahara Desert is the largest hot desert in the world, extending across the whole African continent from east to west. This immense geographical feature has not always been the arid wasteland we know today. The Sahara desert is known to have undergone major, and possibly abrupt, hydrological fluctuations and was vegetated at times in the past. Scientific research has revealed that the Sahara desert and the Sahel were considerably wetter around 9,000, 50,000 and 120,000 years ago then at present, allowing for the growth of trees instead of grasses.

These climatic shifts have had profound implications for human migration throughout history. The wet periods within MIS 3 and 5 coincide with major human migration events out of sub-Saharan Africa, suggesting that changes in AMOC influenced North African climate and, at times, contributed to amenable conditions in the central Sahara/Sahel, allowing humans to cross this otherwise inhospitable region. Understanding this dynamic history is essential to comprehending how nomadic groups have adapted their migration patterns over thousands of years.

Although as large as the United States, the Sahara (excluding the Nile valley) is estimated to contain only some 2.5 million inhabitants—less than 1 person per square mile. This sparse population distribution reflects the extreme challenges posed by the desert environment, yet it also demonstrates the remarkable resilience and adaptability of those who have made the Sahara their home.

Historical Evolution of Nomadic Pastoralism in the Sahara

The transition to nomadic pastoralism in the Sahara represents a critical adaptation to changing environmental conditions. Domesticated livestock appeared in the Sahara almost 7,000 years ago, marking a fundamental shift in how human communities interacted with the desert environment. A large factor in the rise of pastoral nomadism has been due to the desertification of the Sahara since the last wet phase.

The introduction of the camel revolutionized desert life and migration patterns. Although camels were used in Egypt by the 6th century bce, their prominence in the Sahara dates from only the 3rd century ce. This relatively late adoption of the camel had transformative effects on nomadic societies. The camel could carry upward of three hundred pounds of goods an average of fifteen to eighteen miles a day, and its capacity to store fat and water enabled it to travel up to ten days without stopping for fresh water, more than twice the time and distance of almost every other pack animal.

The camel’s unique adaptations to desert conditions made it indispensable for nomadic life. The camel’s unique splayed foot allowed it to walk easily in the soft, sandy conditions of the Saharan environment, enabling desert nomads to reach more distant oases than ever before and so open entirely new routes across the desert. This capability fundamentally altered migration patterns and expanded the geographical range available to nomadic communities.

Major Nomadic Groups of the Sahara

The Tuareg: Masters of Desert Navigation

The Tuareg people are a large Berber ethnic group, traditionally nomadic pastoralists, who principally inhabit the Sahara in a vast area stretching from far southwestern Libya to southern Algeria, Niger, Mali, Burkina Faso, and as far as northern Nigeria. Known in their own language as the Imouhar, meaning the free people, the Tuareg have developed one of the most sophisticated nomadic cultures in the Sahara.

Since prehistoric times, Tuareg peoples have been organising caravans for trading across the Sahara desert. Their role as traders and guides has been central to their identity and economic survival. The Tuareg people are about 2 million nomadic people who live across the Sahara Desert, including in the North African countries of Mali, Niger, Libya, Algeria and Chad.

The Tuareg have maintained a distinctive pastoral economy. The Tuareg are a pastoral people, having an economy based on livestock breeding, trading, and agriculture. They are traders and nomads practicing transhumance, or the seasonal movement of people and livestock between fixed summer and winter pastures. This pattern of transhumance represents a sophisticated adaptation to the seasonal availability of resources in the desert environment.

Other Nomadic Communities

While the Tuareg are perhaps the most well-known nomadic group, they are not alone in the Sahara. Major pastoral groups include the Regeibat of the northwestern Sahara and the Chaamba of the northern Algerian Sahara. The Tebu (Toubou) are a nomadic and semi-nomadic people with a population of around 2 million living in small communities dispersed across northeastern Niger and around the Tibesti Mountains in Chad and southern Libya, tending to livestock and date harvesting in scattered oases.

Despite considerable cultural diversity, the peoples of the Sahara tend to be categorized as pastoralists, sedentary agriculturalists, or specialists (such as the blacksmiths variously associated with herders and cultivators). This categorization reflects the diverse economic strategies employed by different groups to survive in the harsh desert environment.

Geographical Influence on Migration Routes and Patterns

The Dual Nature of the Sahara: Barrier and Corridor

The Sahara has historically functioned as both an obstacle and a pathway for human movement. Its extreme climate and vast size create formidable challenges, yet specific routes through the desert have been used for centuries, creating corridors of movement that connect disparate regions of Africa. Journeys across the desert typically last from three to seven days and are largely impossible to complete without someone who knows the terrain.

Smugglers in the Sahara context traditionally belong to nomadic or semi-nomadic groups which have travelled in the desert for centuries. This deep knowledge of desert terrain, passed down through generations, has been essential for successful navigation and survival. The expertise of nomadic groups in reading the landscape, understanding weather patterns, and locating water sources has made them indispensable guides for anyone attempting to cross the Sahara.

Seasonal Migration Patterns

Pastoralism, always nomadic to some degree, occurs where sufficient scanty pasturage exists, as in the marginal areas, on the mountain borders, and in the slightly moister west. The availability of pasture varies dramatically with the seasons, driving the cyclical movement of nomadic groups.

When animals were unable to graze at oases because of either distance or weather, the nomads were forced to find other grazing land, particularly during the hottest and driest seasons, when the nomads migrated their flocks and herds to the better grazing areas of the Maghreb in the north or the Sahel in the south. This seasonal pattern of movement between different ecological zones represents a sophisticated strategy for maximizing resource availability throughout the year.

During the rainy season, nomadic groups move camp every three to four days in search for the greenest pastures for their livestock, while during the dry season, they move often to find water, but prefer to stay in the vicinity of their “home territory”, land passed down from one generation to the next. This attachment to traditional territories, combined with the flexibility to move in response to environmental conditions, characterizes the nomadic approach to land use in the Sahara.

The Role of Livestock in Migration Decisions

Cattle appear along the southern borders with the Sahel, but sheep, goats, and camels are the mainstays in the desert. The type of livestock kept by different groups influences their migration patterns, as different animals have varying water and grazing requirements.

Bedouin Nomads practice long nomadic movements of a seasonal migration because their lives are related only to camels which demand from them to move deeply into the nowhere of the Sahara desert for diversification of food. The camel’s ability to survive in the harshest desert conditions allows groups that specialize in camel herding to penetrate deeper into the desert interior than those dependent on other livestock.

In drought periods wide migrations in search of pasture took place, with heavy loss of animals. These crisis migrations, driven by environmental catastrophe, could dramatically alter traditional movement patterns and bring different groups into conflict over scarce resources.

Adaptation Strategies to Desert Conditions

Water Resource Management

Access to water is the most critical factor determining nomadic migration patterns in the Sahara. Oases serve as vital nodes in the network of nomadic movement, providing not only water but also opportunities for trade, social interaction, and temporary settlement. Irrigation utilizes ephemeral streams in mountain areas, permanent pools (gueltas), foggaras (inclined underground tunnels dug to tap dispersed groundwater in the beds of wadis), springs (ʿayn), and wells (biʾr).

The knowledge of where to find water in the vast desert landscape represents accumulated wisdom passed down through generations. Nomadic groups have developed sophisticated techniques for locating underground water sources, reading vegetation patterns that indicate moisture, and predicting seasonal water availability based on rainfall patterns and other environmental cues.

Material Culture and Mobility

The nomadic lifestyle requires material possessions that are portable, durable, and multifunctional. Traditional Tuareg tents exemplify this principle. They reside in camps ranging from 50 to 150 people and live in tents of wooden poles covered with a red dyed goat hide tarp. These structures can be quickly assembled and disassembled, allowing for rapid movement when necessary.

The emphasis on portability extends to all aspects of material culture, from cooking utensils to tools and weapons. Items are designed to be lightweight yet functional, and many objects serve multiple purposes. This minimalist approach to material possessions is not merely practical but reflects a deeper cultural value placed on mobility and freedom from encumbrance.

Social Organization and Adaptation

Hierarchical in structure, the larger pastoral groups formerly dominated the desert. This social organization provided both security and efficiency in managing the challenges of desert life. Warfare and raids (ghazw) were endemic, and the hierarchical structure of nomadic societies helped coordinate defense and offensive operations.

The social structure of nomadic groups also facilitated the sharing of knowledge about migration routes, water sources, and grazing areas. Elders who possessed deep knowledge of the desert environment held positions of respect and authority, ensuring that critical survival information was preserved and transmitted to younger generations.

The Trans-Saharan Trade Network

Historical Development of Trade Routes

The Sahara has historically served as a crucial link between sub-Saharan Africa and the Mediterranean world. There are basically five trade routes that extend across the Sahara from the northern Mediterranean coast to the African cities on the southern edge of the desert, with Tuareg merchants responsible for bringing goods from these cities to the north.

During the 9th and 10th centuries, Berbers and Arabs built upon these pre-existing trade routes and quickly developed trans-Saharan and sub-Saharan transport networks. The expansion of these networks transformed the economic landscape of North Africa and created new opportunities for nomadic groups to participate in long-distance trade.

Tuareg camel caravans played the primary role in trans-Saharan trade until the mid-20th century when European colonial infrastructure – railways and roads – were introduced. For centuries, the success of trans-Saharan commerce depended entirely on the expertise and labor of nomadic groups who could navigate the desert’s challenges.

Commodities and Economic Impact

The trans-Saharan trade involved a diverse array of commodities flowing in both directions. Lucrative trade included salt, gold, and slaves. Salt from Saharan mines was particularly valuable in sub-Saharan Africa, where it was essential for food preservation and nutrition. Gold from West African kingdoms flowed northward, enriching Mediterranean economies and funding the growth of powerful Islamic empires.

Because of the nature of transport and the limited space available in caravans, Tuareg usually traded in luxury items, which took up little space and on which a large profit could be made. This focus on high-value, low-volume goods made trans-Saharan trade economically viable despite the enormous costs and risks involved in desert crossings.

As the camel transformed desert transport, the products of sub-Saharan Africa became more readily available to the Mediterranean world, with trade in West African gold expanding and demand increasing for such goods as ivory and ostrich feathers. This increased connectivity had profound effects on both the economies and cultures of regions linked by trans-Saharan trade.

Trade Centers and Urban Development

As cross-desert traffic grew, several new settlements developed to aid the movement of goods north and south of the Sahara, including Sijilmasa, Ghat, Gao, Awdaghust, and Kano. These urban centers served as crucial nodes where caravans could rest, resupply, and exchange goods. They also became centers of cultural exchange where diverse populations interacted.

Trans-Saharan migration has caused trade to flourish and has helped revitalize ancient trans-Saharan (caravan) trade routes and desert (oasis) towns in Mali (Gao), Niger (Agadez), Chad (Abéché), Libya (Sebha and Kufra), Algeria (Tamanrasset), and Mauritania (Nouadhibou). Even in the modern era, these historic trade centers continue to play important roles in regional commerce and cultural life.

Cultural and Religious Exchanges Across the Sahara

The Spread of Islam

The expansion of Islam into North Africa between the 7th and 11th centuries prompted additional groups of Berbers, as well as Arab groups wishing to retain traditional beliefs, to move into the Sahara, with Islam eventually expanding through the trade routes, becoming the dominant social force in the desert. The trans-Saharan trade network served as a conduit for religious ideas as well as material goods.

Tuareg people are credited with spreading Islam in North Africa and the adjacent Sahel region. As traders and travelers, nomadic groups played a crucial role in disseminating Islamic teachings, practices, and culture throughout the Sahara and beyond. However, the Islam practiced by many nomadic groups retained distinctive characteristics that reflected pre-Islamic traditions and beliefs.

Cultural Syncretism and Identity

The movement of peoples across the Sahara facilitated extensive cultural exchange and syncretism. Nomadic groups absorbed influences from the diverse populations they encountered while maintaining distinctive cultural identities. Language, dress, social customs, and artistic traditions all reflect this complex interplay between cultural preservation and adaptation.

Despite the pressures of advancing desertification, periodic rebellions, incursions by bandits and armed subversives, a flood of West African migrants, and the influences of globalization, culture in the Sahara Desert continues to thrive in traditional, adapted and new forms of handcrafts, jewelry, textiles and clothing fashions, dance and performance art, music and poetry. This cultural resilience demonstrates the enduring strength of nomadic traditions even in the face of dramatic social and environmental change.

Knowledge Systems and Navigation

Nomadic groups developed sophisticated knowledge systems for navigating the featureless expanses of the Sahara. These systems incorporated astronomical observation, reading of landscape features, understanding of wind patterns, and accumulated experience of specific routes and landmarks. This knowledge was typically transmitted orally from generation to generation, making it vulnerable to loss as traditional nomadic lifestyles change.

The expertise required to successfully navigate the Sahara extended beyond simple route-finding to include weather prediction, water location, and risk assessment. Successful caravan leaders needed to make complex decisions about when to travel, which routes to take, and how to respond to unexpected challenges such as sandstorms or equipment failures.

Modern Challenges to Traditional Nomadic Migration

Climate Change and Desertification

There have been tight restrictions placed on nomadic life because of high population growth, with desertification exacerbated by over-exploitation of resources including firewood. Environmental degradation has reduced the availability of pasture and water, making traditional migration patterns increasingly difficult to maintain.

Climate change has caused shorter and shorter rainy seasons and longer periods of drought, and hence fewer pastures for the animals to graze. These changes force nomadic groups to adapt their migration strategies or abandon nomadism altogether. This has pushed some Tuareg to experiment with farming; some have been forced to abandon herding and seek jobs in towns and cities.

Political Boundaries and Sedentarization

When African countries achieved widespread independence in the 1960s, the traditional Tuareg territory was divided among a number of modern states: Niger, Mali, Algeria, Libya, and Burkina Faso. The imposition of international borders has severely restricted the traditional migration patterns of nomadic groups, as movement across borders now requires documentation and is subject to government control.

It was only with the advent of colonialism, which drew borders where there had been none and created modern states, that trans-Saharan mobility and trade collapsed, though soon after independence, the foundations were laid for the contemporary trans-Saharan migration system. The colonial legacy continues to shape migration patterns and create challenges for nomadic populations.

Many have been forced to give up their nomadic lifestyle and become sedentary, forming small villages or moving to the cities for work. This transition from nomadism to sedentary life represents a fundamental transformation in social organization, economic strategies, and cultural identity. Sedentary Tuareg villages grow more and more common as livestock herds shrink.

Economic Transformation

In the 1970s and 1980s, forced and voluntary settlement of nomads, wars in the Sahel, and droughts provoked impoverished (former) nomads and traders, such as the Tuareg, to start migrating to work at construction sites and the oil fields of southern Algeria and Libya. The shift from pastoral nomadism to wage labor represents a dramatic economic transformation with profound social and cultural implications.

Earlier migration and settlement of (semi-) nomads in Libya and Algeria set the stage for more large-scale, trans-Saharan migration after 1990, because numerous ex-nomads found new livelihoods in smuggling goods and people across the Sahara. The knowledge and skills developed through generations of nomadic migration have been adapted to new economic activities, some legal and others operating in gray areas or outside the law.

The Oasis System: Critical Nodes in Nomadic Networks

Ecological and Economic Functions

Oases serve multiple critical functions in the Saharan ecosystem and in nomadic migration patterns. They provide water, shade, and opportunities for agriculture in an otherwise inhospitable environment. In the desert proper, sedentary occupation is confined to the oases, where irrigation permits limited cultivation of the date palm, pomegranate, and other fruit trees; such cereals as millet, barley, and wheat; vegetables; and such specialty crops as henna.

For nomadic groups, oases represent essential waypoints on migration routes and trade journeys. They offer opportunities to rest, water livestock, trade goods, and gather information about conditions elsewhere in the desert. The relationship between nomadic pastoralists and sedentary oasis dwellers has historically been complex, involving both cooperation and conflict.

Social Dynamics at Oases

Oasis dwellers in the Sahara were increasingly subject to attack by the Sanhaja (a Berber clan) and other camel-mounted nomads, with many of the remaining oasis dwellers, among them the Haratin, subjugated by the nomads. This history of conflict and domination shaped social hierarchies and power relationships in Saharan societies.

Beyond settlements, the nomadic pastoralists dominated the Sahara, though there were other peoples in the desert, including small groups such as the Haratin who also called the oases home, harvesting dates and digging salt to exchange for food but often kept in a subordinate position by the nomads, who controlled the oases. This social stratification reflects the power dynamics created by control over critical resources in the desert environment.

Gender Roles and Social Structure in Nomadic Societies

Matrilineal Traditions

Many Saharan nomadic groups, particularly the Tuareg, maintain distinctive gender roles and social structures that differ from surrounding societies. Although they are Islamic, they retain a matriarchal organization, and the women of the Tuareg have an unusual degree of freedom. This matrilineal system affects inheritance, social status, and family organization.

The relative freedom and status of women in Tuareg society has long fascinated outside observers. Women play important roles in cultural transmission, economic activities, and social decision-making. This gender dynamic reflects both pre-Islamic traditions and adaptations to the demands of nomadic life.

Social Hierarchy and Specialization

Nomadic societies in the Sahara typically feature complex social hierarchies and specialized occupational groups. These social structures help organize labor, maintain order, and preserve specialized knowledge and skills. Different groups within nomadic societies may specialize in herding, trading, crafts, religious leadership, or military activities.

The hierarchical nature of these societies has historically provided both stability and flexibility, allowing nomadic groups to coordinate large-scale activities such as caravan organization while maintaining the ability to disperse into smaller units when necessary. However, these traditional social structures are increasingly challenged by modern economic and political realities.

Contemporary Nomadic Life and Future Prospects

Persistence of Nomadic Traditions

Despite enormous pressures toward sedentarization, nomadic traditions persist in the Sahara. Some groups continue to practice full nomadism, while others have adopted semi-nomadic lifestyles that combine seasonal migration with periods of settlement. The persistence of these traditions reflects both cultural attachment to nomadic identity and the continued economic viability of pastoralism in certain contexts.

Modern nomads face the challenge of maintaining traditional practices while adapting to new realities such as national borders, market economies, formal education systems, and technological change. Some groups have successfully integrated modern technologies such as mobile phones and GPS devices into traditional nomadic practices, using these tools to coordinate movements, access market information, and maintain social connections.

Cultural Preservation and Adaptation

Efforts to preserve nomadic cultures face significant challenges but also show promising developments. Cultural organizations, museums, and educational initiatives work to document and celebrate nomadic traditions. Some nomadic groups have found ways to market their cultural heritage through tourism, crafts, and cultural performances, creating new economic opportunities while maintaining cultural continuity.

The future of nomadic migration in the Sahara will likely involve continued adaptation and transformation rather than simple preservation or disappearance. Hybrid forms of nomadism, combining traditional practices with modern innovations, may emerge as viable strategies for maintaining cultural identity while responding to changing environmental and economic conditions.

Policy Implications and Support

Government policies toward nomadic populations vary widely across North African countries, ranging from active support for pastoral livelihoods to pressure for sedentarization. Effective policies must balance respect for nomadic traditions and rights with the need to provide services such as education and healthcare. International organizations and development agencies increasingly recognize the value of nomadic knowledge systems and the importance of supporting sustainable pastoral livelihoods.

Land tenure issues remain particularly contentious, as nomadic groups often lack formal legal recognition of their traditional territories and migration routes. Securing land rights for nomadic populations is essential for protecting their livelihoods and cultural practices, but this requires legal frameworks that can accommodate mobile populations and seasonal land use patterns.

The Sahara’s Influence on Regional Connectivity

Historical Connections Between North and Sub-Saharan Africa

The Sahara has served as a crucial link connecting North Africa with sub-Saharan regions for millennia. Rather than isolating these regions from each other, the desert facilitated exchanges of goods, people, ideas, and technologies. Nomadic groups played essential roles as intermediaries in these exchanges, translating between languages, mediating cultural differences, and facilitating commercial transactions.

The trans-Saharan connections established through nomadic migration and trade had profound impacts on the development of civilizations on both sides of the desert. West African kingdoms such as Ghana, Mali, and Songhai derived much of their wealth and power from participation in trans-Saharan trade, while North African cities flourished as commercial and cultural centers linking the Mediterranean world with sub-Saharan Africa.

Contemporary Migration Patterns

In the Sahara context, the delineation of “transit” becomes blurred, with many desert locales being simultaneously areas of origin, transit and destination, at least temporarily. Modern migration across the Sahara involves complex patterns that reflect both historical continuities and new dynamics driven by economic disparities, political instability, and globalization.

Contemporary trans-Saharan migration includes labor migration, refugee movements, and irregular migration toward Europe. Smugglers generally cooperate with local corrupt police, border officials, and intermediaries who connect them to employers in Europe. The infrastructure and knowledge systems developed through centuries of nomadic migration continue to shape these contemporary movement patterns, though in dramatically transformed contexts.

Environmental Knowledge and Sustainability

Traditional Ecological Knowledge

Nomadic groups have accumulated sophisticated environmental knowledge through generations of experience living in and moving through the Sahara. This knowledge encompasses understanding of plant and animal ecology, water resources, weather patterns, and sustainable resource management. Traditional practices often embody principles of sustainability that modern resource management is only beginning to appreciate.

The seasonal migration patterns of nomadic pastoralists, for example, prevent overgrazing by allowing pastures to recover between periods of use. The diversification of livestock species helps spread risk and utilize different ecological niches. These traditional practices represent valuable knowledge for addressing contemporary environmental challenges in arid regions.

Lessons for Modern Resource Management

As climate change intensifies pressures on arid environments worldwide, the adaptive strategies developed by Saharan nomads offer important lessons. Flexibility, mobility, diversification, and deep environmental knowledge all represent valuable approaches to managing uncertainty and variability in harsh environments. Integrating traditional nomadic knowledge with modern scientific understanding could contribute to more effective and sustainable resource management strategies.

However, realizing this potential requires recognizing nomadic groups as knowledge holders and active participants in environmental management rather than as obstacles to development or conservation. Policies and programs that support nomadic livelihoods and incorporate nomadic knowledge can contribute to both cultural preservation and environmental sustainability.

Conclusion: The Enduring Legacy of Nomadic Migration

The impact of the Sahara Desert on nomadic migration in North Africa represents one of the most remarkable examples of human adaptation to extreme environments. For thousands of years, nomadic groups have developed sophisticated strategies for surviving and thriving in one of Earth’s most challenging landscapes. Their migration patterns, shaped by the desert’s geography, climate, and resources, have in turn shaped the cultural, economic, and political development of North Africa and beyond.

The trans-Saharan trade networks established and maintained by nomadic groups connected distant regions and facilitated exchanges that enriched civilizations across Africa, the Mediterranean, and the Middle East. The cultural traditions developed by nomadic societies reflect both the constraints imposed by the desert environment and the creative responses of human communities to those constraints.

Today, traditional nomadic migration faces unprecedented challenges from climate change, political boundaries, economic transformation, and cultural change. Yet nomadic traditions persist, adapting to new realities while maintaining connections to ancient practices and identities. The future of nomadic migration in the Sahara will depend on the ability of nomadic communities to continue adapting while preserving core cultural values, and on the willingness of governments and international organizations to support sustainable nomadic livelihoods.

Understanding the historical and contemporary dynamics of nomadic migration in the Sahara offers valuable insights into human adaptability, cultural resilience, and sustainable resource management in challenging environments. As the world faces increasing environmental pressures and the need for sustainable development strategies, the lessons learned from Saharan nomads become ever more relevant. Their experience demonstrates that human societies can thrive in even the most difficult environments through flexibility, knowledge, cooperation, and deep connection to place.

For those interested in learning more about the Sahara Desert and its peoples, resources such as the Britannica Encyclopedia’s comprehensive article on the Sahara provide detailed information. The Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences offers scientific research on climate change and human migration in North Africa. Organizations like Amman Imman work to support Tuareg communities through water access projects. The Migration Policy Institute provides analysis of contemporary trans-Saharan migration patterns. Finally, the Peabody Museum at Harvard offers exhibitions and educational resources on Tuareg culture and material heritage.

The story of nomadic migration in the Sahara is far from over. As these communities continue to navigate the challenges of the 21st century, they carry forward traditions and knowledge developed over millennia, adapting ancient wisdom to new circumstances and demonstrating the remarkable resilience of human cultures in the face of change.